Article

Why it’s time to rethink scope 3 strategy

Scale and collaboration remain the challenges, but how can they be achieved? Experts point to the changes in business relationships and strategy that can shift the needle

Share

2026 has brought extreme wildfires across Europe and North America, devastating floods and landslides in Asia, and increasingly frequent extreme weather events bringing the consequences of climate change into sharper business reality – disrupting supply chains, threatening production and increasing costs.

Yet, even as the need for climate action becomes more urgent, the political and commercial environment for delivering it is not becoming easier. New research from GlobeScan, ERM and Volans highlights the scale of the challenge. In 2026, 77% of European sustainability experts reported significant backlash against sustainability and ESG, up from 59% in 2024. Meanwhile, just 5% of experts surveyed believe most companies will meet their 2030 climate commitments.

The findings highlight a growing disconnect between corporate climate ambition and confidence in delivery. For companies tackling scope 3 emissions, this is particularly significant. Much of the investment needed to meet their commitments lies beyond their direct operations, in supply chains where their influence and financial control are limited.

Recent conversations with corporate sustainability leaders, including at Innovation Forum’s scope 3 conference in Amsterdam, suggest that some of the assumptions underpinning scope 3 strategies are now being questioned.

The investment dilemma

One of the biggest challenges is the business case for supply chain decarbonisation.

For buyers, investing in their own operations can deliver long-term efficiency gains, lower energy costs and greater control over future spending. The financial calculation becomes more complicated when that investment is directed towards a supplier’s operations. A company might help finance new equipment in a supplier’s factory without owning the asset or knowing whether it will still be purchasing from that supplier in five years.

For suppliers, the calculation is equally difficult. They are increasingly being asked to invest in cleaner technologies, equipment and production processes, often at considerable cost. Without longer-term purchasing commitments, suppliers have little certainty that the customers requesting these changes will still be buying from them in six or 12 months, let alone over the lifetime of the investment.

The result is a commercial stalemate. Buyers are reluctant to finance assets they don’t own, while suppliers cannot justify major investments without confidence in future demand.

Rethinking procurement relationships

Breaking this deadlock requires a more fundamental shift in how companies work with their suppliers.

For years, supplier engagement has focused heavily on emissions reporting, target-setting and individual decarbonisation projects. These activities have an important role, but they cannot overcome investment barriers if the underlying commercial relationships remain unchanged.

Companies may need to reconsider how purchasing decisions are made, how long-term demand is communicated and how the costs and risks of decarbonisation are shared.

Longer-term contracts can give suppliers greater confidence to invest. Joint financing can distribute costs between buyers and suppliers, while collaboration between companies can create sufficient demand to make lower-carbon technologies commercially viable.

There are various initiatives which are already demonstrating how these approaches can work, including:

  • Landscape Enterprise Networks (LENs): Businesses including Nestlé and Diageo are pooling investment to support regenerative agricultural practices across shared sourcing landscapes, helping farmers make improvements that benefit multiple buyers.
  • Energize: Brings together 27 pharmaceutical companies, to help suppliers overcome barriers to renewable electricity procurement through collective purchasing and expert support. A new collaboration with EcoVadis’s Responsible Health Initiative is now extending access to more suppliers across the pharmaceutical value chain.
  • Zero Emission Maritime Buyers Alliance (ZEMBA): Major freight buyers are aggregating demand for lower-emission shipping services, creating stronger commercial incentives for shipping companies to invest in cleaner fuels.

These initiatives take different approaches, but they share an important principle: suppliers are more likely to invest in decarbonisation when there is a credible commercial case for doing so.

Scaling a new approach

The challenge now is how to take these approaches to scale, and where responsibility for delivering emissions reductions should sit.

Collaborative investment programmes and long-term purchasing agreements do offer promising models, but they cannot provide a solution for every supplier or sector. Companies need to make more deliberate decisions about where direct investment is necessary, where procurement can create the right incentives and where suppliers should take responsibility for their own transition.

This also requires a shift in how businesses assess the returns from decarbonisation. In some supply chains, the strongest case for investment may lie in protecting future supply, improving resilience and reducing exposure to climate-related disruption, rather than carbon savings alone.

Ultimately, the rethink may need to go beyond individual supplier programmes. If scope 3 commitments are to translate into meaningful emissions reductions, procurement decisions, supplier contracts and investment priorities must support the changes companies are asking their suppliers to make.

With 2030 approaching, the question is whether businesses are prepared to change these commercial relationships, and how they can do so at the scale required.

These challenges will be central to Innovation Forum’s Scope 3 Innovation Forum, taking place in Amsterdam on 15–16 June 2027, under the theme The next phase of Scope 3: Investment, impacts and returns.

Register here to get involved. 

Author details

Natasha Bodnar

Project Director

Join our network

Stay updated with the latest news, insights and updates

Sign up

Author details

Natasha Bodnar

Project Director

Related events

View all events
Conference

2nd - 3rd December 2026

New York City, USA

02
December
Cross-sector

The Climate Resilience Innovation Forum USA

2nd - 3rd December 2026

New York City, USA

Conference

16th - 17th March 2027

London, UK

16
March
Cross-sector

Responsible Sourcing and Ethical Trade Forum

16th - 17th March 2027

London, UK

Conference

15th - 16th June 2027

Amsterdam, Netherlands

15
June
Cross-sector

The Scope 3 Innovation Forum

15th - 16th June 2027

Amsterdam, Netherlands